Pros and cons of trait theory shannonsleadershipcorner. Foley the great man theory presented by james buck 3614 summary the great man theory was a popular 19th century idea according to which history can be largely explained by the impact of great men, or heroes. As the behavioral sciences grew, so did the idea that leadership is more of a science that can be learned and nurtured. This theory is totally based on the ability of the leader, to inspire the work force to put their best in. Bates, in international encyclopedia of education third edition, 2010. These initial studies formed what is referred to as the great man theory of leadership. The great man theory asserted that men, mainly in the upper class, inherit leadership. In society many people still believe in the great man theory, leaders are born, not made. He was one among the significant social commentators of this time and. Contemporary surveys of leadership scholarship will occasionally mention the great man theory before moving on to more rigorous academic categories.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of the great man. There must be a certain morality in place to pursue a shared vision for everyone if this leadership style is to succeed. The great man theory of leadership dates back to the times of the ancient greek and romans. According to this theory capacity for leadership is inborn that is a person is either a natural.
Pros and cons of trait theory the essence of leadership. Being a student within sdsus hospitality and tourism management program, which focuses on training future leaders in the hospitality industry, i think that traits do play a part in leadership, though these leadership traits are not. The great man theory of leadership ppt linkedin slideshare. May 17, 20 some of the pros and cons of this theory are listed below. According to the theory, leadership calls for certain qualities like charm, persuasiveness, commanding personality, high degree of intuition, judgment, courage, intelligence, aggressiveness and action orientation which are of such a nature that they cannot. Less a theory than a statement of faith, the great man theory does not fit into the rigorous scholarly theory and research that makes up the contemporary canon of leadership discourse.
Leadership characteristics are passed through the genes either you have them or. A leader is a hero who accomplishes goals against all odds for his followers. However, it is my belief that anyone can become a great leader with practice, passion, and willingness to learn and grow. Strengths and limitations of the great man theory strengths of the great man theory has certain qualities like, persuasiveness, charm, demanding personality, increase amount of perception, courage, intellect, aggressiveness and be action orientated which skills that they cannot be taught or learned. Starting point for the understanding of which human traits make great leaders. Leaders of organizations may not have the force of character to achieve that. The mythology behind some of the worlds most famous leaders such as abraham lincoln, julius caesar, mahatma gandhi and alexander the great helped contribute to the notion that great leaders are born and not made.
This approach stands out from other leadership styles in its ability to quickly assess an organizations current situation and formulate a vision for its improvement and growth. Feb 22, 20 the trait and great man theories have many pros and cons. Sep 07, 2016 these initial studies formed what is referred to as the great man theory of leadership. Some of the pros and cons of this theory are listed below. It believes in inspiring employees to do great work through example and the force of a leaders personality. Pros and cons of trait theory to me, the trait theory is one of those theories similar to when people thought the world was flat. Historically, the role of the head in such schools peters, 1976 provided the foundation for the great man theory of leadership where autonomy, authority, religion, and morals jointly defined an omnipotent role for the headmaster, perhaps best put by thring of uppingham.
Great man theory of leadership management study guide. The advantage of the great man theory as opposed to the marxist theory of history is that it has huge amounts of examples that make for easy storytelling and explanation. However, the trait theory is more about characteristics that help to make and improve leadership skill, and the great man theory is about a leader is born to be a leader with all skills to. For example if we only look at how they changed history instead of what they did we fo. This steps away from the great man theory by arguing that leaders can be made, and are not necessarily born with innate traits. The great man theory leadership development for higher. Taking two different test subjects and stating what their reactions will be to similar situations is not possible. Jun 25, 2015 working under a great leader is a privilege that can be far too rare, but even more rare is a definition of what makes a great leader. Although both theories seem to be valid and can be proven with examples, many instances arise where these theories are proven wrong and dont hold true. Eventually the great man theory evolved into the trait theories. Pros and cons of trait theory delightedly undecided. Leadership theories the great man theory this is perhaps the most controversial theory of all times. Pros and cons of trait theory the name on the front.
It is simply fact that many leaders have usurped the existing balance o. The top advantages and disadvantages of transformational leadership show us that leaders using this method can take teams to new heights or bigger lows. A pro of trait based theory is that people can work to become a leader. The great man theory originated from studying behaviors of military figures and people in authority in the 1800s. Apr 22, 2018 the great man theory of leadership ppt 1. During these studies, trait theorists focus on measuring the traits displayed and defining the habitual patterns seen in areas of behavior, thought, and emotion. Pros and cons of trait theory the leadership lessons. Despite spencers arguments to the contrary, the great man theory remained the popular and predominant theory for explaining and understanding leadership until the mid20 th century. Having a list of traits associated with certain qualities provides a clear representation of what a successful leader may look like, therefore provide people with manners in which to go about becoming an admirable leader. In 2014, gallup published a study suggesting that companies hire the wrong person for the job as much as 82 per cent of the time, and that only one in ten people have the skills to be a good manager. The pros and cons of trait theory theleadershipwolf. Leadership theories great man theory great leaders grow.
This is the great man theory of leadership which asserts that leaders in general and great leaders in particular are born and not made. Com the great man theory of leadership the great man theory simply refers to the impact of great men or heroes, highly influential persons who, due to either their personal charisma, intelligence, wisdom, attitude or political skill utilized their power in a. The great man theory of leadership became popular during the 19thcentury. It suggested that the course of human history results largely from the actions of great men, or in other words, that certain figures were responsible for the bulk of the goings on in the world. Mar 19, 2015 dear world, as my school leadership teacher points out. The paper compares and contrasts great man theory of leadership with a more collaborative and inclusive style of leadership. The trait theory or great man theory offered one of the earliest conceptual ways of looking at leadership. There are positive aspects about the trait theories. Carlyle, freud, and the great man theory more fully. The great man theory of leadership what is great man theory. This theory is linked to the work of the historian thomas carlyle and was proposed during the 19 th century 1840s according to which history can be largely explained by the impact of great men or heroes and that great leaders are born and not made.
Mar 31, 2019 the dream of the great man theory to find universal characteristics of leadership remains out of reach, and is still controversial in the scientific community. What are the strengths and weaknesses of trait theory. These traits you are just born with and they cant be learned. Leadership characteristics are passed through the genes either you have them or you do not. The great man theory, collective leadership, and scholar practitioner 11 words 5 pages bailey, 2004. Dear world, as my school leadership teacher points out. The mythology behind some of the worlds most famous leaders such as abraham lincoln, julius caesar, mahatma gandhi, and alexander the great helped contribute to the notion that great leaders are born and not made. Strengths and limitations of the great man theory strengths. Research does not provide one single answer nor all the answers, but is good food for thought what is this great man theory. The great man theory this term paper explains the leadership style of the great man theory, by thomas carlyle, a historian of nineteenth century. The author uses her own experience of being surprised by her attraction to behaving as a great man even as her knowledge, gender, training and experience would dictate otherwise.
Analysis of the pros and cons of different leadership. This is a leadership theory which says that neither a transactional leadership model, nor a transformational model of leadership will work in all situations and all the time. There is lots of literature and recipes for leadership. Trait theory is a psychological study of an individuals personality. Because leadership couldnt be learned or taught, a certain level of divinity was attributed to them. The subjects of these studies are put through similar situations and monitored as to what their reactions will be. Leaders were men who were born with the qualities needed to run businesses. Pros and cons of trait theory and great man theory posted on february 20, 2017 february 20, 2017 by edleading as we have discussed before, a good leader must have the necessary traits and attributes to be successful.
Pros and cons of trait theory posted on february 16, 2014 by michelek47 the trait theory is based off of the great man theory which entails that all of the worlds achievements can be attributed to the actions of great men. Back then, leadership was correlated with unique, specific mental, physical or personal characteristics. Every year, i read the biographies of great leaders. Even with the detailed research that was recorded during the trait theory studies, trait theorists found weaknesses that existed. Hello readers, in an effort to better understand what being a great leader is, i have been actively researching trait theory in society many people still believe in the great man theory, leaders are born, not made. I believe that a leader is not born, a person thrown into leadership because his dad was a leader has a chance of not succeeding.
The great man theory is one that was popular in the earlymid nineteenth century. Feb 20, 2016 both the trait theory and the great man theory attempt to identify leaders and what makes leaders. May 06, 2019 despite spencers arguments to the contrary, the great man theory remained the popular and predominant theory for explaining and understanding leadership until the mid20 th century. Analysis of the pros and cons of different leadership theories. Great man theorists found that personality traits were correlated with leadership abilities, and that great people were born with innate characteristics and qualities that distinguished them from other notso great people northouse, 2016. In addition, there was also what used to be called great man theories. The great man theory of leadership the future leadership. Both the trait theory and the great man theory attempt to identify leaders and what makes leaders. He was one among the significant social commentators of this time and has presented many lectures during his lifetime. After numerous studies, you can see how different traits are easily shared and identified with top leaders today. Thomas carlyle, a great historian, was heavily involved in. Feb 22, 20 in addition, there was also what used to be called great man theories.
Great man theorists found that personality traits were correlated with leadership abilities, and that great people were born with innate characteristics and qualities that distinguished them from other notsogreat people northouse, 2016. Thomas carlyle believed that effective leaders were a package of godly motivation and the right personality. Transformational leadership is a more humane theory, as compared to the militaristic transactional theory. Behavioral theory behavioral types of leadership theories of which there are many focus on how leaders behave in the workplace. Further, behavior theory looks at the word leadership as a characteristic that one can develop. Sep 12, 2015 hello readers, in an effort to better understand what being a great leader is, i have been actively researching trait theory. Pros and cons of trait theory and great man theory semester. This theory holds that there is one best way to lead and that deeply seated personality variables allow certain people to master that best way. History great man theory is explained as the impact of great men or heroes highly influential individuals a person that is born with or without the necessary traits of leadership this concept is based on the belief that great leaders are not. One of the cons to this theory is times have significantly changed since the adoption of this theory and you can now have anyone whether there male or female from any level. The famous historian, thomas carlyle was deeply involved with this great man theory of leadership and had even stated that the history of this world was basically the combined biographies of these great men. Leadership in management and the great man theory essay.
Well, once upon a time, in the year 1841, a man called thomas carlyle. I also write down the characteristics i admire in each person as a way to emphasize to my subconscious what i would like to emulate. Feb 20, 2017 pros and cons of trait theory and great man theory posted on february 20, 2017 february 20, 2017 by edleading as we have discussed before, a good leader must have the necessary traits and attributes to be successful. I have fun categorizing them and guessing their preferred style. The theories or concepts of leadership such as the great man theory, collective leadership, and scholarpractitioner are ideas that transformed the way leaders lead.
These theories believed that leadership skills were inherited by mainly men in the upper class. These eight leadership theories vary in their consideration of these components. Pros and cons of trait theory the trait theory and the great man theory both talk about what traits and different types of characteristic make a leader. The great man theory however says that leaders are inherently born, not made. Feb 21, 2016 pros and cons of trait theory the trait theory and the great man theory both talk about what traits and different types of characteristic make a leader. The trait and great man theories have many pros and cons. The dream of the great man theory to find universal characteristics of leadership remains out of reach, and is still controversial in the scientific community. Pros and cons of trait theory and great man theory. I will compare pros and cons for both theories to show this. This theory believes that people rise higher through positive, than negative motivation.
Mar 03, 2014 the great man theory was a popular 19th century idea according to which history can be largely explained by the impact of great men, or heroes. The great man theory assumes that the capacity for leadership is natural cherry. Com the great man theory of leadership the great man theory simply refers to the impact of great men or heroes, highly influential persons who, due to either their personal charisma, intelligence, wisdom, attitude or political skill utilized their power in a way that had a decisive historical impact. However, in recent times, its articulation within the business environment has been challenged by many commentators. The great man theory says that leadership traits are instilled in a person when they are born. The great man theory of leadership states that some people are born with the necessary attributes that set them apart from others and that these traits are responsible for their assuming positions of power and authority. Great man theory or great man of leadership theory, was established on 19th century by thomas carlyle, scottish philosopher, historian, satirical writer and essayist. First, behavior theory supports the idea that leadership traits can be learned through development and experience. The basic idea of the theory is that leaders are born and not made. Pros and cons trait based theory is a way of identifying leaders to non leaders.
938 1453 745 200 1239 221 98 928 1506 484 335 144 1090 263 1473 1098 881 1030 1392 501 1010 485 1028 426 198 1448 748